The shorter, wider bench was built straight from the plans on the site.  I modified the 2nd bench to be taller and not as wide. The darker bench was done earlier in the summer and were stained with the last bit of stain in the can. I used the same wood, and stain on the 2nd bench and they came out lighter. They were finished in mid September. Probably the product of not stirring well enough. Overall, we're very happy with our patio set.